Knife Design Using Computer Software
Posted 08 December 2011 - 09:36 AM
The software that I use for design work is Corel Draw. I have version X4. Corel has version X5 out now. I’ve had Corel Draw software on my computers for years. I've had versions that Corel sold through the last 10 years and they were all capable of this type of work.
Draw is not inexpensive software. I'm sure that there are CAD programs and other drawing software that is less expensive; though I have no experience with them, so cannot suggest what else you could use. Google has a drawing program called SketchUp. There is a free version of it, but I have never tried it out. It may be worth checking into. I will show what features in Draw make it simple for me to use, so that you can look for these features in other software.
There are several benefits (for me) in using a computer to design my knives. I am not so good at drawing with a pencil. After I get done scratching around with a pencil, the lines are not precise and the paper is covered with eraser smudges. If I need more than one copy of the drawing, I have to either use carbon paper to trace it, or scan it on a flat-bed scanner. Too, pencil lines are much thicker than the lines that can be generated on the computer and printed. The thin printed lines are much easier to cut and grind to.
I have a stack of French curve and drafting templates, but using these limits you to the plastic shapes that you have on hand. The shapes that I can create on the computer are limitless. I also find it difficult to use a French curve to draw one side of a part that needs to be symmetrical, then flip the French curve over and locate it perfectly to draw the other half of the part. When designing a symmetrical part on the computer, I just design one half of the part, duplicate it, reverse it and paste it to the first half.
If the drawings do not fit on a 8 ½ X 11 sheet of paper, I can have the software print the drawing across multiple sheets of paper to create a full size drawing of the knife. The sheets of paper overlap each other and each sheet has reference marks so they can be aligned accurately.
I also use the software to design the patterns that use for engraving. Draw has a tool that creates scrolls. The scrolls that it makes are not perfect in shape, but it is easy to clean up the scroll by using the Shape Tool. I can also create leaves and other elements to complete the engraving patterns. I save all of the elements that I create so that they are available for me to use again. Each saved element can be easily resized, rotated, flipped, or reshaped to use it in another pattern.
I'll start posting up information on how I use Draw to create knife designs and also how I use the printed drawings to cut out knife parts. Hope you enjoy!
Posted 09 December 2011 - 08:41 AM
This is a photo of the pattern glued to the guard material for cutting out.
Jumping to another knife project image; I use Super Glue to attach the paper pattern to the fitting material. I sometimes first use stick paste glue to adhere the center of the pattern to the material. The paste glue gives me a few seconds to get the pattern aligned with reference marks on the material before it tacks up. I then lift the edges of the paper pattern and put a liberal amount of Super Glue under the paper. I use a Q-Tip to press the pattern down and push the excess Super Glue from under the pattern. I do this by rolling the Q-Tip from the center of the pattern to the edges. The Super Glue can soften the printer toner, so you do not want to slide the Q-Tip on the pattern as it may wipe the lines away. The cotton end of the Q-Tip will absorb the excess Super Glue as it is pressed from under the paper.
I've found Super Glue to be the best type of glue to use for this work. It sticks the pattern down firmly and also binds the fibers of the paper together. When grinding out parts with a paper pattern attached, the fibers at the edges of the paper will tear out and make the edge of the paper fuzzy. This makes it more difficult to see the printed lines. The Super Glue binds the fibers together so the paper grinds away clean.
All of the glues that I have tried for this work are heat sensitive. They will release if you get the part too hot while cutting and grinding. So, you have to exercise a little patience. I do all of the cutting and grinding with my bare hands so I can feel the temperature of the material. If the part is getting too hot to hold, I need to let it cool down. The Super Glue makes the paper fairly waterproof, so it is often possible to cool the part in water, but I usually just put it down for a few minutes. If the paper pattern does begin to come loose, I just lift edge of the paper with a toothpick and stick it back down with more Super Glue.
This photo is of the dagger guard cut out using the paper pattern.
A paper pattern was also used on the bottom of this guard.
This photo is of the full size image of the dagger design, printed on two sheets of paper. You can see the spiral fluted handle in the printed pattern. This is actually a photo of the handle of another dagger that I had made. In Draw, you can use a photograph to create a Pattern Fill. Once I had created the Fill from the handle photo, I was able to use it to fill the handle area on this knife design.
Back to the bowie guard; I printed the guard design on transparency film and transferred it to the guard for cutting the interior pattern with my engraving tools.
Posted 09 December 2011 - 11:58 PM
This is an excellent topic and will provide some additional design tools for us to use. I am already looking into the different software applications that are available and am reading about and researching the features in both Corel Draw and Adobe Illustrator. So far the weight of opinion by graphic artists is that Corel Draw has less of a learning curve than Adobe Illustrator.
Posted 10 December 2011 - 07:25 AM
The accuracy of the drawings is the best thing about using the software. Plus, the ability to put reference lines on the drawings to align with reference marks on the materials.
There is a learning curve for Draw. The "Help" menu is pretty good, but Draw is capable to SO much that it is sometimes confusing until you understand how to make things work. I am still learning how to use features of Draw and continually discovering more ways to use it for knife designing. Hopefully, this thread will help anyone who chooses Draw to learn to use it quickly. Too, I am available to answer anyone's questions.
I will continue adding to this thread and will show specifically how to do certain things with Draw. It takes a while for me to work through the series of things I have to do to get post ready. So, be patient. I have a lot to show.
Posted 12 December 2011 - 09:43 AM
Supposing that I want to design an oval guard for a bowie; I select the "Ellipse" tool from the Tool Menu at the left side of the screen (red arrow). Simply click and drag the cursor to create the oval. To get the size that I want for the guard to be, I type the size in the menu bar at the top of the screen (red circle).
Every element that you create has a vertical and horizontal position on the page. Giving the element a specific position allows you to add other parts to the element in the correct position. I have given the oval its location on the page by typing coordinates in the x and y boxes (green circle).
After selecting the "Freehand" drawing tool (red arrow), I created a line to be centered on the oval. This line will be used to center the paper pattern on the guard material. This line is also given a position for its location (green circle).
I usually also add a line to the drawing that will be where the top of the blade will set against the face of the guard. That's all there is to designing an oval guard for a bowie.
I start the construction of the guard by milling the tang slot in a piece of raw material. During the machining operation, I put a pointed tool in the spindle of the milling machine and use it to make drag marks on each end of the guard material. These marks are centered on the tang slot. The guard material is then fitted to the blade tang.
Once the blade has been fitted to the guard material, I make a mark on the material at the top of the blade. The pattern is glued to the guard material using the drag marks to align it with the center of the tang slot and the mark from the top of the blade to position the pattern vertically on the material.
Posted 13 December 2011 - 07:46 AM
The pattern on the left is for one of my hunting knife models. I have the guard patterns for my model knives saved on my computer. When I am ready to make the guard for one of these knives, I can just go to the computer and hit print to get a copy of the pattern.
This guard pattern (left pattern) is made up of an oval shape that is of the height and width that the guard will be. A circle is placed at the top of the oval to define the top of the guard. I could add straight lines to connect the outer edges of the oval and circle where the edge of the guard will be, but I just grind the guard against the flat platen until the edge of the guard material is parallel with the lines. The horizontal line is where the top of the blade will be. This line is 1/16" below the top of the guard. This gives me plenty of room to roll the handle on the flat platen to grind the handle material level with the top of the guard and not hit the edges of the spine.
If you want the top of your guard to be flat, you can use a square to define the top of the guard, instead of a circle (center pattern). If you prefer the top to be flat with rounded corners (right pattern), the corners of the square can be rounded by changing the settings in the "Corner Rounding" box (green circle).
Posted 14 December 2011 - 07:09 AM
This is an excellent design tool and I appreciate your tutorials that show how to use this software application for bladesmithing. I can see how it would ensure accurate, consistent, and creative results.
Well, I did my research on pricing and comparison with other software drawing applications and decided to purchase Corel Draw Suite 5X which is the latest version. The retail price is $499 but I purchased it through Amazon.com where it is now on sale for $215.
Number of downloads: 2
Posted 15 December 2011 - 09:36 AM
The image below is of one half of a guard for a dagger. Take note of the width of this element. It is 1.822" wide (green circle). I want to place this half of the guard with the left side at 2.5" from the edge of the sheet. Adding half of the width of the drawing (.911) to 2.5 equals 3.441. I have typed the horizontal position of 3.441" and the vertical position of 9.5" into the location box (red circle).
I create a duplicate of the right half of the guard by clicking on the "Duplicate" function in the "Edit" menu.
An exact duplicate of the right half is created.
Reverse the duplicate by clicking the "Mirror Horizontally" button.
I place it on the sheet in alignment with the first half by typing in the 9.5" vertical location. Then, subtract one half of the width of the element from 2.5". The horizontal position of 1.589" is typed into the x location box.
Posted 18 December 2011 - 07:35 AM
A generic term for any item you create or place in a drawing.
A line is a path between two points. Line segments have nodes at each end, which are depicted as small squares.
The square points at each end of a line or curve segment. You can change the shape of a line or curve by dragging one or more of its nodes.
A straight line has control nodes at each end. The control nodes at the ends of straight lines do not have control handles for shaping the line into a curve, so a straight line is always straight.
A line that has nodes with control handles, which you can manipulate to change the object's shape. A curve object can be any shape, including a straight or curved line.
In the image below is a Straight Line. The small squares at the ends of the line are nodes. These nodes can be used to move the line on the sheet, but cannot be used to shape the line into a curve.
After selecting the "Shape" tool (red circle) the small squares become arrows. Click on one of the arrows.
Clicking on the arrow will display the "Convert Lines To Curve" icon (green circle). Click this icon and the line will be converted to a Curve Line. The nodes at the ends of the line will change to Control Nodes that have Control Handles.
The control handles can then be moved using the Shape Tool.
Posted 18 December 2011 - 08:26 AM
I received my Corel Draw Suite 5X software from Amazon yesterday and installed it on my PC. I will start reading the documentation and learning the application. I am looking forward to using it in my work and will be following your instructions in this thread.
Posted 20 December 2011 - 08:24 AM
With the rectangle selected, I have opened the Arrange Menu and clicked on "Convert To Curves". Then, I have selected the Shape Tool and clicked on one of the corner Nodes. This will turn on the Nodes Properties menu (above the green line).
Use the cursor to click on the "Convert To Curves" icon, on the Nodes Properties bar (green circle).
This will change the line that the Node is adjacent to into a curve. The Nodes on this line will have Control Handles. You will need to do this with each Node that you wish to convert to curves.
The lines can now be shaped, using the Shape Tool.
Control Nodes can be deleted from the shape by double clicking on them with the Shape Tool.
You can add Nodes to a line by placing the Shape Tool on the line where you want the Node to be and then double clicking.
Posted 20 December 2011 - 06:47 PM
I'm waiting for my Corel Draw X5. I also ordered from Amazon.com. Hopefully I will recieve it tommorrow so I can play with it over the holidays.
I want you to know how much we appreciate the time and effort you have taken for this project! Time is a very precious commodity.
I had a Cad program years ago. The learing curve was very lengthy. I'm looking forward to this program helping my design and layout.
Posted 21 December 2011 - 07:57 AM
Glad that you like this thread. Yea, it takes some time to do all of the screen captures and edit them for posting.
There is a learning curve for Draw. I am trying to make this thread a step by step learning tool, so if you follow along with what I have done in this thread and do what I have shown here, you will pick up the essential knowledge.
The first thing that you need to learn is how to change straight lines in Objects to Curve Lines. Curve lines with Control Nodes, are what you need for creating your own shapes.
The tutorials and the help menu in Draw are pretty good, but include too much detail on doing things that are not so important for designing knives. At least, not to begin with. There are some really cool features in Draw that I'll get into later. But for now, I'll focus on the basics. I expect to be posting on this thread for quite a while. I'll get into higher detailed drawings as I go.
If anyone using Draw has a question, or has a problem accomplishing anything in Draw, post your question up in this thread and I'll answer it.
Posted 22 December 2011 - 08:00 AM
Using node types
You can change the nodes on a curve object to one of four types: cusp, smooth, symmetrical, or line. The control handles of each node type behave differently.
Cusp nodes let you create sharp transitions, such as corners or sharp angles, in a curve object. You can move the control handles in a cusp node independently of one another, changing only the line on one side of the node.
With smooth nodes, the lines passing through the node take on the shape of a curve, producing smooth transitions between line segments. The control handles of a smooth node are always directly opposite one another, but they may be at different distances from the node.
Symmetrical nodes are similar to smooth nodes. They create a smooth transition between line segments, but they also let you give lines on both sides of a node the same curve appearance. The control handles of symmetrical nodes are directly opposite each other and at an equal distance from the node.
Line nodes will change curve objects back to a straight line.
In the illustration below, I have created three straight lines, converted them to Curves, double-clicked near the center of the lines, using the Shape Tool, to add another Control Node. I then used the Shape Tool to pull the new center Node upwards to demonstrate what each Node type will do.
The center Nodes have been changed to three different types of Curve Nodes. The Node type is changed by clicking on the icons on the Node Control Panel (green circle).
Another option available is to break the Curve. This is done by selecting a Node with the Shape Tool and then clicking on the Break Curve icon (green circle). When you break a curve, two control arrows appear at the ends of the line segments (zoom box).
The Shape Tool can be used to grab one of the Control Handles (the arrow heads)and separate the two line segments.
Posted 30 December 2011 - 08:07 AM
Using Draw, I can design a slip-joint folder in about 15 minutes. This does not include the time that I spend staring at the screen and trying to decide what I want the knife to look like; but is the amount of time actually spent manipulating the pattern on the screen.
I almost always start a blade design by using the Rectangle Tool. This allows me to choose the dimensions for the height and length of the blade. I have selected the Rectangle Tool and created a rectangle that is 2 12" by 1/2".
At this point, I will introduce the "Snap To" feature. Using Snap To allows you to automatically align objects with points on the grid and/or to other objects. Rather than go through a lengthy explanation here of how snapping works, I suggest that you read about it in Draw's Help menu.
The Snap To controls can be found in the View drop down Menu, I have set the properties to "Snap to Grid" and also "Snap to Objects". Dragging the rectangle to a place on the sheet where I want the blade to be, it has Snapped to a position on the Grid.
In the image below, I have clicked on the Arrange Menu and selected Convert To Curves. Selected the Shape Tool from the Toolbox. Then, double-clicked on the lower left Node to delete it.
I have clicked on the remaining left Node to select it and then on the Node Toolbox I selected the Convert Line to Curve icon. This gives the Node Control Handles.
I have now used the Control Handles on the left Node and the lower right Node to begin shaping of the blade edge.
I double clicked on the line that forms the blade spine to add a Node and pushed the node up to the Grid. I now have the start to a nice clip-point blade shape.
Posted 31 December 2011 - 01:12 PM
Using the Pick Tool, I moved the small rectangle to the end of the blade shape where it snapped into position (Snap to Object function).
On the Toolbar, I have selected the Basic Shapes icon and then selected Flowchart Shapes. This opens a Toolbar (green circle)where you can choose from different available shapes. I selected the shape of a circle with cross-hairs inside it. This shape is great for locating holes to be drilled. The cross-hairs help with aligning a center punch.
Dragging the cursor on the sheet will create the circle shape. I then typed into the Size Box the dimensions for a 1/8" circle. This is the size of the pivot pin that would be used on this knife.
Using the Pick Tool the circle is dragged to the middle of the small rectangle where it will Snap to the center of the rectangle. You will see the word "center" appear when you drag an object to the center of another object.
To add the kick to the blade, I used the Triangle Shape tool. Make a triangle, rotate it around to the correct position, drag the control handles to size it about right and then snap it to the bottom of the blade.
Now, it is time to turn all of these separate objects into one object. So, I will Group them to create one object. The Pick Tool is used to drag a Selection marquee around the blade. This will select all of the objects that make up the blade. Then, the Arrange Menu is opened and Group is selected.
Double click on the blade with the Pick Tool and put in Rotate mode. In the center of the blade is a small circle with a dot inside of it. This is the center of rotation for the blade shape.
Moving the Pick Tool, over the Rotation center, the cursor will turn to a cross-hair shape. Hold down the left mouse button and the Rotation Center can be dragged to a new position. I have dragged the Rotation Center to the middle of the blade tang, where it will automatically align with the center of the Circle with Cross-hairs. You will see the small word "center" appear when you have the Rotation Center positioned correctly.
Clicking twice on the blade again, the Rotation Handles will appear. The Rotation Handles can be used to rotate the blade shape, pivoting on the new rotation point in the center of the tang. Or, you can type a rotation amount in the Angle of Rotation window.
Posted 31 December 2011 - 01:14 PM
This has nothing to do with designing a folder, but is something that you should know about. The first time that you use some of the features in Draw, like the Duplicate function, a window will pop up asking you to specify the location where the duplicate will be placed on the sheet, relative to the position of the original object. What you type in this window is not important. If you type in 0 and 0, it will place the duplicate exactly over the original. The next time that you use this feature, Draw will use your previous settings as the default location for duplicates. You will not see the pop up window appear. You can change any of the settings later by going to the Tools menu and selecting Options. There is a whole slew of settings available in Options where you can specify how features function.
You need the duplicate blade placed exactly over the original blade. If your duplicate function did not do this. Either drag the duplicate into position, or check the location of the original blade shape, then type in this same location for the duplicate blade.
Double click on the duplicate blade to display the Rotation Handles and the duplicate blade can be rotated to a new position, pivoting on the same rotation center as the original blade. With the duplicate blade in this position, you can use it for designing the knife handle.
Posted 05 January 2012 - 07:24 AM
Start by clicking on the blade spine about 1/16" in front of the spring notch, to add a node there. Click again near the bottom of the blade. Place another node past the end of the rotated blade and then click again on top of the first node to make an enclosed object. The exact placement of these four nodes is not important, as they can and will be moved later.
Using the Shape Tool, click on the top left node and then select the Convert Line To Curves icon on the toolbar. This will turn on the control handles for shaping.
Use the Shape Tool to select each of the nodes and convert the lines to curves.
Use the control handles to begin shaping your handle design. You can also use the Shape Tool to drag the nodes to different locations. Rotate the duplicate blade into and out of the handle shape as needed to design the handle and make the knife look as you want.
You can add a node anywhere you like by double-clicking on the line with the Shape Tool.
Posted 08 January 2012 - 08:18 AM
However, I've used Google's SketchUp as well as Illustrator (yes, huge learning curve but so worth it especially if you also use photoshop), Aurodesk Sketchbook, and AutoCAD (not for the non-professional and the not-rich, but amazing) for designing and laying out woodwork for years. The Google program works well, is free, and I was happy with it. The advantage of Autodesk is you can draw on a tablet and then import it into something else if you want to and it's simple. Illustrator can be anightmare so get one of the training classes on CD if you are going to use it. However we use it for technical publications and it's very powerful.
For most woodcarving, furniture making, etc. I still use the Google program as there is a large community of woodworkers who adopted it. Ton if info on the Fine Woodworking site on it (mostly in the blogs and forums...)
Great tutorial, Steve, wish I had one like that when I started Illustrator.... I cussed a lot and spend a lot of time on the phone with tech support.
John Updike - The Dance of Solids